In an overnight deal, three-time Cy Young winner Max Scherzer agreed to run it back with the American League champion Toronto Blue Jays. Both parties agreed to an attractive one-year deal full of incentives.
The agreement includes a $3 million salary and $10 million in incentives. Insider Ken Rosenthal confirms that the bonus starts at the 65-inning mark. It also comes with no-trade protection.
Last season, Scherzer struggled to stay healthy and consistent during the regular season. He was only able to make 17 starts, and posted a 5.19 ERA in 85 innings. However, when the postseason fell, the two-time World Series winner hit the big time with a 3.77 ERA in three starts. Not the least of which was his courageous start in Game 7 in the World Series against the LA Dodgers, when he allowed only one run in 4.2 innings, and left with a 3–1 lead.
Scherzer returns with Blue Jays for 19th MLB season
It was already clear after the heartbreaking outcome of that Game 7 loss that the 41-year-old was determined to return in 2026. "I can't understand how this is the last pitch I ever throw," he said in early November.
He suffered from a thumb problem throughout the '25 season, which also caused pain in his arm and shoulder. It seems like he believes he has it figured out and will be ready to endure the rigors of his 19th major league season.
Given his age and late signing date, Scherzer will take his time getting ready for the season. But by adding depth to the rotation and a valuable clubhouse presence, he will be a key piece for manager John Schneider to once again rely on in times of need. Even if he is sometimes afraid that Mad Max will kill him.
