chelsea Youngster Kendry Paez's momentum at River Plate has taken another turn, following a difficult night on the heels of his first Superclásico start that raised new questions about his role - and ultimately, over his future on loan.
The 18-year-old, on loan from Chelsea, was given a starting chance against Boca Juniors Making an impact on the bench just a few days ago. However, River suffered a 0–1 defeat at the Monumental and Paez struggled to make an impact before being substituted after 57 minutes.
This was a sharp contrast to his recent performance, and could again impact how Rivers manages his minutes moving forward.
From impact subs to tough superclásicos
Páez earned his place in the XI after changing the game against Carabobo, where he came on and provided the assist for the winning goal in just 39 minutes.
That performance propelled him into contention and, ultimately, into the starting lineup for one of the biggest fixtures in South American football. Against Boca, however, the context was very different.
River dominated in periods of possession but lacked cutting edge and Paez struggled to impose himself between the lines. Although he showed personality from time to time, his overall contribution remained limited.
The numbers reflect that struggle. He had 32 touches but did not register a single shot. He completed 9 of 16 passes and failed to complete one dribble.
Furthermore, he lost too many possessions, lost possession 15 times and could not provide the creative spark River needed.
Criticism follows performance
The demonstration did not go unnoticed in Argentina. River legend Reinaldo "Mostaza" Merlo offered a candid assessment after the match, questioning both Paez's impact and physical presence. His words were relayed hail.
"I thought Páez would not play because he only played a little bit against Carabobo. He played well for a short period of time [against Carabobo] Nothing else."
"I have watched him since he arrived and he is a soft player. Coudet inserted players inside to keep the ball. They had the ball at times, but lacked depth and danger. Then they struggled to be clinical."
He then criticized the player's attitude as he was carried off the pitch and showed no 'sorrow or regret' after the final whistle.
"Losing a derby always hurts. It hurts. You have to endure as long as it takes and then you have to start again."
The criticism highlights the level of scrutiny Paez now faces, especially in high-pressure matches.
What this means for Chelsea and loans
For Chelsea, such ups and downs are part of the development process. Paez is still adapting to a new environment, a new tactical system and the demands of a club like River.
However, it also reinforces uncertainty about their role. he went away from there having an unused optionFor a game-changing option, for a starter in the biggest match of the season - and now under question again after a quiet performance.
That inconsistency matters in the context of his debt. Rivers wants to keep Páez involved and playing regularly, especially with a system in place that could allow Chelsea Reevaluate his situation if his minutes drop too low.
Performances against Boca do not necessarily change long-term plans, but they may influence short-term decisions on selection and usage.
So after an extraordinary performance following a tough Superclásico, the next few weeks could prove crucial in determining whether Páez can secure a stable role – and whether River can maintain control of his loan situation.
